May 2nd, 2008
Ah yes, the Moonbats of Berkeley are still at it. The Berkeley Daily Planet is running an opinion piece by Mark McDonald, a member of the Berkeley Peace and Justice Commission, the same group that pushed a resolution calling the marine Recruitment Center “unwelcome and uninvited.” Where does the City of Berkeley find these people?
From the Berkeley Daily Planet:
Many people familiar with the Berkeley City Council’s resolution calling the Marines Corps Recruiters unwelcome intruders and the resulting protests might be surprised to learn that they had been deliberately bamboozled into believing that the Berkeley leaders were insulting the men and women who serve in the Marines. The mass hysteria was fanned by the nation’s mostly pro-war media who were willingly led by the nose by Republican war hawks. Their goal was to paint war critics like Berkeley as unpatriotic haters of the troops and to deflect attention from the disgraceful behavior of the Marine Recruiters which was the topic of the Berkeley resolution.
“Bamboozled”? Hardly! And there were more resolutions against the marines passed than just the one McDonald cites in his piece. For instance the granting of free permits (the kind of permits other groups have to pay fees for) to Code Pink for their weekly protests in front of the recruitment center and calling on Berkeley residents to do anything they can, including the use of intimidation, to impede the activities of marine recruiters.
“Pro-war media”? What has this guy been smoking?
“Disgraceful behavior of the Marine Recruiters”? Back that up with hard evidence!
McDonald continues:
The recruiters have long been guilty of not honoring the agreements and contracts they make with recruits. Though not a new problem, this dishonest activity continues and has even been ratified by some conservative high court decisions.
Provide hard-copy, verifiable evidence. If there are court cases, cite those cases.
This next part is really nutty:
Recently the Pentagon has been failing to meet minimum recruitment goals most likely because of the unpopularity of the Iraq War and the fear of permanent deployment of troops due to stop-loss regulations. The Republican administration does not want to activate a draft because sending the sons (and daughters) of the middle and wealthy class families to war is what hastened the end of the Vietnam War. In order to dupe more young people into enlisting, the Pentagon has initiated a new program titled “Try One,” where a wavering recruit is told they can enlist for one year and then leave if they choose to do so. After the year they are then informed that due to Stop Loss regulations they cannot leave and end up permanently deployed.
First off, there is no such thing as a “popular war.” Wars are never popular, especially with those asked to fight it. Sometimes wars are necessary, or unavoidable. World War 2 was both. Whether or not Vietnam was necessary can be debated, although it was probably avoidable.
The real gem in this piece is this: “The Republican administration does not want to activate a draft because sending the sons (and daughters) of the middle and wealthy class families to war is what hastened the end of the Vietnam War.” McDonald has bought into the lie that the volunteer military is an “economic draft” and only people with no other choices enlist into the Armed Forces. This is a blatant insult to every man and woman who has chosen to serve in the military.
Not only that, McDonald has not done his homework on who is serving in the Armed Forces: Predominately they are middle-class Americans. People from backgrounds similar to my own when I enlisted back in 1983. Don’t believe me? Check out the Heritage Foundation 2006 report on who is serving.
From the HF report:
The percentage of recruits from the poorest American neighborhoods (with one-fifth of the U.S. population) declined from 18 percent in 1999 to 14.6 percent in 2003, 14.1 percent in 2004, and 13.7 percent in 2005.
That means as of 2005, 86.3% of recruits are coming from middle and upper class families. So much for the lie of the volunteer Army being an “economic” draft and being made up of our nation’s poorest and least educated.
Demographic evidence discredits the argument that a draft is necessary to enforce representation from racial and socioeconomic groups. Additionally, three of the four branches of the armed forces met their recruiting goals in fiscal year 2005, and Army reenlistments are the highest in the past five years.
The Heritage Foundation has an additional report here that is also worth reading.
McDonald continues to get his facts wrong when he asserts “In order to dupe more young people into enlisting, the Pentagon has initiated a new program titled “Try One,” where a wavering recruit is told they can enlist for one year and then leave if they choose to do so.”
The Try-One program is for prior service active duty troops who are considering signing on to the National Guard. It is not available to new recruits who have never served.
From Military.com:
Bonus Tip. The one year trial plan. Both the Army Guard and Air National Guard offer the “Try-One” enlistment option to active duty veterans and all prior service individuals who are joining the Guard for the first time. This program lets you try the Guard for one year without additional commitment.
McDonald continues:
The Berkeley people and their Council are not against the Marines or any other enlisted personnel. The Marines are our sons, daughters, husbands, wives. fathers, mothers, uncles, aunts, cousins, etc. The Marines are us and ours and it is our duty to protect them and all American enlisted from losing their health and lives in illegitimate adventures for profit by liars and criminals.
Question to McDonald: Have you served in the Marines? Or any other branch of the Armed Forces? If not, then don’t claim to be one of “us”. You may not agree with the war in Iraq, however that does not make it an “illegitimate adventure for profit.” And who are the liars and criminals? If you want to make such allegations, back it up with hard-copy evidence, not empty rhetoric.
Based on the evidence at hand, Mark McDonald of the Berkeley Peace and Justice Commission has earned himself a Moonbat Award for his efforts in distorting the facts and spewing stupidity in the finest Berkeley tradition.
Tags:
Berekely Marines Moonbat McDonald Economic Draft
Posted in American Politics, Armed Forces, Moonbat Award | No Comments »